SARDAR UDHAM : Say it like Shoojit Sircar

Shoojit Sircar is a man of quiet depth and restrained emotions. Even when he makes his lighter films, there is a unique elegance and classy charm attached to them, them studded with precious gem like moments, deeply layered subtlety, and an inexplicable repeat watch quality where you keep discovering a new something with every repeat watch. When the news first started flowing around that my most favourite hindi filmmaker of today’s times was going to make a biopic on Sardar Udham Singh and had the incredible Irrfan on his mind to play the titular role, it was naturally very exciting. While there were apprehensions about Shoojit also jumping into the biopic bandwagon, and also indulging in a genre that was outside his comfort zone, I also had the confidence that Shoojit, with his research , detailing, aesthetics and restraint, will lend the right amount of depth and gravitas to the forgotten story of this valiant revolutionary who took all his time but never lost focus on seeking justice on possibly the single most heinous crime and the darkest event of blood bath that marred India’s struggle for independence.

And it is so heartening to note that Shoojit Sircar and his film sparkles through and through, in spite of him stepping into uncharted territories, in spite of the tragic passing away of Irrfan in between and Vicky Kaushal stepping in to fill the very large shoes, and in spite to Shoojit Sircar going against the tide of telling a patriotic story with minimalistic quietitude, zero jingoism, and with the unsettling heaviness of a piercing slowburn. Sardar Udham couldn’t have been a better film under any other filmmaker and any other actor, both of them giving their everything to create an undeniable stunner. That’s how you conceive a film, that is where you take your ambition in terms of scale and canvas, and that is how you execute with precision. All this, even when the film really takes time to take off for the first hour or so, even when you know a tighter edit of some of those parts could have rested this miniscule crib and turned it to be a flawless masterpiece. But such is the mastery of Shoojit Sircar’s execution, so brilliant is his team with terrific cinematography with Avik Mukhopadhyay (yet again), goosebump inducing background score by Shantanu Moitra, outstanding production design by Mansi Dhruv Mehta and Dmitriy Malich, brilliant sound design team and the rest of the crew, that one is completely transported into a different lived in atmospheric world even when it is completely alien to you, absorbing you completely in that milieu, never giving a scope to feel disengaged in spite of its slow pace. In fact, while there was some work to be cut out on the editing table (and there was possibly scope to take away may be 30 minutes from the 165 minutes running length of the film), full credits to editor Chandrashekhar Prajapati for seamlessly presenting one of the best non linear retelling of a heart wrenching real life story over multiple timelines.

Infact, the initial slow pace designed by Shoojit Sircar and his editor is completely intentional because they want to suck in the audience and settle them down in the world that they are going to rattle very very soon going down the pages of history. Shoojit and his perceptive writing team of Ritesh Shah and Subhendu Bhattacharya are more interested in exploring the Why of the mindspace of Udham Singh rather than the How the events unfolded, and hence it was important to give them the time to fully get there for us to understand the extent of horror that unfolded at the Jallianwala Bagh, the extent of helpless death and destruction that our protagonist experienced, and how it shaped his psyche to stay focused on his single most agenda of finishing of Michael O’Dwyer for decades without getting too much perturbed by the larger macroscopic landscape of the overall struggle for independence. The non-linear storytelling helps take the plot to its crescendo over time at its most opportune moment, even when the film opens with a note on what happened at the Jallianwala Bagh in the opening credits, and we also witness Udham Singh successfully executing Micheal O’Dwyer early on in the film. As the story progresses jumping back and forth over timelines, we get to understand the cold blooded shrewdness and cruel inhumanity of O’Dwyer and Dyer, their non chalant pride of executing the darkest of mass murders in history, and the indomitable spirit and the determined resolute strength of Udham Singh to seek some justice and closures over them in due course. And what do we say about how Shoojit Sircar and his team stages the horrific massacre and its heart wrenching aftermath of Udham Singh and team trying to find and save lives from the heap of death. It surely has to be one of the most brilliantly executed final hours of a hindi film in a long long time. The repetitive restaging of valiant effort by Udham Singh to rescue any residual lives from all the gore around him only adds to the impact of the tragedy and the horror that followed the actual incident. The incident of Jallianwala Bagh has been adapted to screen earlier as well, but this has to be the bleakest, most fearless and most disturbing depiction of that horror and the entire team of Sardar Udham deserves a huge shoutout for raising the film to such rousing heights without any cry for patriotic fervor, without any incessant dialoguebaazi, and without feeling the need to pretty up or sanitize the scale of destruction. In many ways, I was reminded of the opening scenes of Saving Private Ryan and that’s quite a benchmark to hit in the depiction of such earth shattering destruction.

And yet all of this would have fallen flat had central performance of Vicky Kaushal wouldn’t have been what it is in the film. Without any spec of doubt, he has delivered the performance of his lifetime as Sardhar Udham, which will also go down as the Best Performance we have seen by any actor in Hindi Cinema this year. Shoojit Sircar has now made this a habit in film after film, from Deepika Padukone in Piku to Varun Dhawan in October to now Vicky Kaushal in Sardar Udham, where each one of them have effortlessly slipped into these characters to become them, totally sunk themselves into the world that Shoojit creates and then deliver their most naturally moving performances of all times in these films. With Udham Singh, Vicky Kaushal also gets a much larger canvas to show a solid character arc over decades, and he excels in his performance to depict every lifestage of Udham Singh so convincingly. Of course he shines the brightest as the young Udham haplessly in love with Reshma and helplessly losing out his fight to save lives from a grotesque blood bath he escaped incidentally. Somewhere up there, Irrfan would be feeling incredibly proud with what Vicky Kaushal has achieved as Sardar Udham.

And it is just not Vicky who shines. Shaun Scott as Michael O’Dwyer and Andrew Havill as General Dyer are as menacing as they need to be. Even the rest of the English cast are all in good form, and it is a relief that unlike most of the other Hindi films set up in the era of the British rule, the English characters here are not cardboard caricatures and are not trying to speak Hindi in funny accents for the most part. Banita Sandhu is again smartly used by Sircar without giving her dialogues to mouth, and her sweet innocence shines in the rare tender moments between her and Udham. The rest of the Indian actors are apt as well and give a well rounded footing to this brilliant film.

It has been about ten hours or so now that I have finished watching Udham Singh, and I have to confess that I still feel choked. The film left me shaken and deeply disturbed, so much so that I could hardly sleep through the night, trying to process what I just saw, and being emotionally moved like anything. But I didn’t regret the fact that I stayed up late to experience this superlative film. There’s so much that the rest of biopic makers in hindi cinema can learn from Shoojit Sircar about how to tell a historical story. Strike that. There is so much hindi filmmakers can learn from Shoojit Sircar about how to make cinema in all its understated grandeur, about how to be fearless in experimenting with various genres, various formats, and never ever creating a film that does not have the Shoojit Sircar class. I for one couldn’t have been happier as a very very proud fan!

To Shoojit Sircar! To Vicky Kaushal! To Sardar Udham!

Sardar Udham is now playing on Amazon Prime Video.

If you like this content, please share the link for further reading.


Copyright ©2021 Jayashree Chakravarti.This article cannot be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL can be used instead.

JAMUN : Deliciously Warm

Raghubir Yadav’s sincere and heartfelt portrayal of the central character in Gaurav Mehra’s “Jamun” is one of the lesser talked but highly memorable performances of the year, and went unnoticed primarily because the film wasn’t watched and discussed as much as it should have been.

Make time for Jamun and Raghubir Yadav. It would be time well spent.

Jamun has been playing for a while now on Eros Now and Jio Cinemas.

If you like this content, please share the link of this article for further reading.


Copyright ©2021 Jayashree Chakravarti. This article cannot be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL can be used instead.

MIMI : Lacks Empathy

When you are talking about sensitive topics like surrogacy, adoption, disability and motherhood, it is criminal trying to lighten it up with jokes drawn from bigotry, wrapped up sleeze, beauty bias, white redemption and everything else that hurts the very sentiments that are the focal point of your film.

And no, not even a very powerful Kriti Sanon and the always reliable Pankaj Tripathi can do much if the intent was never there to explore the depth and the nuances of the complex emotions with the honesty and the gravitas that the topic deserves and demands.

If you like this content, please share the link of this article for further reading.


Copyright ©2021 Jayashree Chakravarti. This article cannot be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL can be used instead.

TOOFAAN : Doesn’t have the firepower

TOOFAAN could have been a completely forgettable film because the sports drama and rise of the underdog template has nothing new to offer. But it still leaves a definitive footprint because it has a beautiful love story at its core whose beating heart and heartfelt moments is the strength of the film. It also has a certain dignified grace as a family drama that works through its ups and downs. The sincerity and hard work of Farhan Akhtar clearly shows, but it is Mrunal Thakur and her spunk that makes Toofaan a significantly better film than the disaster that the trailer indicated.

Oh Ananya!

If you like this content, please share the link of this article for further reading.


Copyright ©2021 Jayashree Chakravarti. This article cannot be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL can be used instead.

HASEEN DILLRUBA : Poorly Pulpy

Kanika Dhillon has a knack for creating delicious characters. But doesn’t she also need to master what to do with them eventually?

Vinil Mathew picks up the right cast to play those delicious characters, and extracts very engaging performances from them to make them rather exciting. But does he believe that a film can thrive merely on excellent performances?

Pulpy trashy novels within your script can be interesting inspirations to orchestrate the filmy twists in your story. But don’t the writer and the filmmaker have the responsibility to ensure their film eventually doesn’t become that inspiration?

If you like this content, please share the link of this article for further reading.


Copyright ©2021 Jayashree Chakravarti. This article cannot be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL can be used instead.

RAY : No Traces of Ray Here

Forget Me Not | Srijit Mukherji – This may be one of the better films Srijit Mukherji has made in recent times overall, but digs its own grave by using some of the highly objectionable ‘Srijit-ish’ tropes to add some gimmicky glitz and forced darkness to the story. It somehow survives due to some decent performances by Ali Fazal and Shweta Basu Prasad and an okayish overall screenplay. The final memory lane trip depiction is rather unclever and literary though, and takes away some more sheen from the film.

Continue reading “RAY : No Traces of Ray Here”

SHERNI : The Tigress on the Run

The Tigress out there is fighting alone to survive in a jungle that’s turned into a mess by anarchy, whims and fancies of a bunch of bad boys! The rot is deep, the traps are furious, the adversary exists in various forms! The metaphor is strong and leaves its pug mark trails throughout the length of the film.

Amit Masurkar had enough meat here to stew a sumptuous experience with a lingering after taste. Unfortunately at times his process remains inconsistent, and the uneven switch between slow burn docu style storytelling and the parallel layered complex human drama doesn’t deliver the necessary gripping bite to stay uniformly invested throughout.

Continue reading “SHERNI : The Tigress on the Run”

SANDEEP AUR PINKY FARAAR : Layered with Smartness

When Dibakar Banerjee makes a film, you watch it.

You can be assured it will be smart, intriguing, layered, and unlike anything what you have seen in the genre before. You can also be assured that he will even make Arjun Kapoor act and Parineeti Chopra get back to form. And you can be assured that the film stays with you for all the right reasons.

So when Dibakar Banerjee makes a film, you watch it. Period.

If you like this content, please share the link of this article for further reading.


Copyright ©2021 Jayashree Chakravarti. This article cannot be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL can be used instead.

ZINDAGI IN SHORT : Stories of Love

‘Zindagi in Short’, now streaming on Netflix, has to be amongst the most fresh anthology offerings of recent times, and also the one that tries least hard to be smart or edgy. A set of 7 short films, each under 20 mins, have been directed by a range of filmmakers, and the stories are of different flavours, representative of a multitude of life dynamics, simple to complex. There is a good mix of established to relatively unknown faces here, both in front of and behind the camera.

Continue reading “ZINDAGI IN SHORT : Stories of Love”

AK vs AK : Meta Musings of Life

There is a reason why I think Vikramaditya Motwane is the most versatile, most fearless and most creative filmmaker currently working in Mumbai! The man doesn’t care whether his art will trigger the ringing of cash registers at the box office, but he will go to any length to make the most impressive films in the genres he will pick up, and challenge both art and life through it! And he will control his indulgence too. And then keep it accessible for all without trying to go too tangential. AK vs AK is another bold step towards establishing it!

Continue reading “AK vs AK : Meta Musings of Life”